Institutional Fact – ZE1

Validation status:  Validated

ZE1 Institutional Fact

Scope note:

An instance of institutional fact is an ascription of a status function to an object by a community. The institutional fact is a concretization of a collective intentionality of the community in question towards a certain object over a certain period of time.

An instance of institutional fact is recognizable to a competent speaker/member of a symbolic community (native or learner with sufficient competence). It may not be perceived through a single sense impression but through multiple experiences and implicit reasonings (e.g.: embedded participation, behavioural observation, linguistic evidence and interview), yet typically such intermediate observations and inferences are not necessarily recorded or accessible. The historical statement is typically the assertion of the institutional fact, that such and such a fact was the case, and was in force for a given given community, at some time. The epistemic veridicality of the stated /reference instance of institutional fact is always open to contestation. The means of contestation involve analyzing the sources which support it.

Instances of institutional fact come into existence based on conventions establishing the conditions under which they come into effect. Typically, an instance of institutional fact will come into existence either because of the performance of its stipulated, initiating speech act (e.g.: state of being married via marriage) or as a result of events fulfilling existing norm prescriptions in the community (e.g.: state of being uncle as result of birth of child of sister).  An institutional fact comes to be through the agreed fiat of a community. It typically ceases to exist either because of a stipulated, nullifying speech act (e.g. divorce proceeding), because a community ceases to support the effective rule supporting its declaration (e.g.: ownership of people) or force majeure (e.g.: object ascribed function/status or community perceiving status is eliminated).

Examples:

  • The Ownership Status (ZE8) of the Gʼpsgolox totem pole (E22) as 'has current owner' the Haisla people (E74) from 1872 - 2012 holds for the Haisla people (E74) and as 'has current owner' the Swedish National Museum of Ethnography (E74) from 1929 - 2006 held by the Swedish Polity. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%CA%BCpsgolox_totem_pole)
  • The Classifactory Status (ZE4) of the "French baguette" (E55) as 'has type' "Intangible Cultural Heritage" (E55) 2022 - Present holds for UNESCO (E74) (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-63800674)

In First Order Logic:

  • ZE1(x) ⇒ E2(x)

Scope notes

Show Scope note Language Namespace View details Comments Validation
An instance of institutional fact is an ascription of a status function to an object by a community. The institutional fact is a concretization of a collective intentionality of the community in question towards a certain object over a certain period of time. An instance of institutional fact is recognizable to a competent speaker/member of a symbolic community (native or learner with sufficient competence). It may not be perceived through a single sense impression but through multiple experiences and implicit reasonings (e.g.: embedded participation, behavioural observation, linguistic evidence and interview), yet typically such intermediate observations and inferences are not necessarily recorded or accessible. The historical statement is typically the assertion of the institutional fact, that such and such a fact was the case, and was in force for a given given community, at some time. The epistemic veridicality of the stated /reference instance of institutional fact is always open to contestation. The means of contestation involve analyzing the sources which support it. Instances of institutional fact come into existence based on conventions establishing the conditions under which they come into effect. Typically, an instance of institutional fact will come into existence either because of the performance of its stipulated, initiating speech act (e.g.: state of being married via marriage) or as a result of events fulfilling existing norm prescriptions in the community (e.g.: state of being uncle as result of birth of child of sister).  An institutional fact comes to be through the agreed fiat of a community. It typically ceases to exist either because of a stipulated, nullifying speech act (e.g. divorce proceeding), because a community ceases to support the effective rule supporting its declaration (e.g.: ownership of people) or force majeure (e.g.: object ascribed function/status or community perceiving status is eliminated). en Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing 0 Denied (see comment)
An instance of institutional fact is an ascription of a status function to an object by a community. The institutional fact is a concretization of a collective intentionality of the community in question towards a certain object over a certain period of time. An instance of institutional fact is recognizable to a competent speaker/member of a symbolic community (native or learner with sufficient competence). It may not be perceived through a single sense impression but through multiple experiences and implicit reasonings (e.g.: embedded participation, behavioural observation, linguistic evidence and interview), yet typically such intermediate observations and inferences are not necessarily recorded or accessible. The historical statement is typically the assertion of the institutional fact, that such and such a fact was the case, and was in force for a given community, at some time. The epistemic veridicality of the stated /reference instance of institutional fact is always open to contestation. The means of contestation involve analyzing the sources which support it. Instances of institutional fact come into existence based on conventions establishing the conditions under which they come into effect. Typically, an instance of institutional fact will come into existence either because of the performance of its stipulated, initiating speech act (e.g.: state of being married via marriage) or as a result of events fulfilling existing norm prescriptions in the community (e.g.: state of being uncle as result of birth of child of sister).  An institutional fact comes to be through the agreed fiat of a community. It typically ceases to exist either because of a stipulated, nullifying speech act (e.g. divorce proceeding), because a community ceases to support the effective rule supporting its declaration (e.g.: ownership of people) or force majeure (e.g.: object ascribed function/status or community perceiving status is eliminated). en Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing 1 Validated

Examples

Show Example Language Namespace View details Comments Validation
The Ownership Status (ZE8) of the Gʼpsgolox totem pole (E22) as 'has current owner' the Haisla people (E74) from 1872 - 2012 holds for the Haisla people (E74) and as 'has current owner' the Swedish National Museum of Ethnography (E74) from 1929 - 2006 held by the Swedish Polity. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%CA%BCpsgolox_totem_pole) The Classifactory Status (ZE4) of the "French baguette" (E55) as 'has type' "Intangible Cultural Heritage" (E55) 2022 - Present holds for UNESCO (E74) (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-63800674) en Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing 0 Denied (see comment)

Additional notes

Show Notes Type Language Namespace View details Comments Validation

Identifier: ZE1

Official URI: https://ontology.swissartresearch.net/aaao/ZE1_Institutional_Fact
OntoME URI: https://ontome.net/ontology/c739

Labels

Label Language Last updated View details Comments Validation
Institutional Fact en 2023-10-31 0 Validated

* : Standard label for this language

Parent classes

Class Class namespace Relation defined in Justification View details Edit Delete Comments Validation
E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing 0 Validated

Ancestor classes

Class Depth Class namespace Via
E1 CRM Entity 2 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3 E2
Thing 3 OntoME internal model - active version E2 - E1

Child and descendant classes

Class Depth Class namespace Via
ZE2 Appellative Status 1 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE3 Contact Point Status 2 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing ZE2
ZE4 Classificatory Status 1 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE5 Function Status 2 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing ZE4
ZE6 Social Status 2 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing ZE4
ZE7 Custodial Status 2 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing ZE30
ZE8 Ownership Status 2 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing ZE30
ZE10 Family Status 2 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing ZE55
ZE11 Membership Status 1 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE12 Referential Status 1 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE14 Similarity Status 1 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE15 Set Status 1 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE30 Property Right Status 1 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE25 Dating Status 1 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE28 Obligation Status 2 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing ZE45
ZE32 Institutional Status 3 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing ZE4 - ZE6
ZE45 Promisory Status 1 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE50 Authority Status 3 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing ZE4 - ZE6
ZE55 Social Relation Status 1 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE56 Witness Status 2 Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing ZE12

Related classes

Relation Class Class namespace Justification Relation defined in View details Edit Delete Comments Validation

Outgoing properties (this class is domain)

Domain Property identifier Range Namespace
ZE1 Institutional Fact aaao:ZP1 has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) E1 CRM Entity Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE1 Institutional Fact aaao:ZP113 has successor status (is successor status of) ZE1 Institutional Fact Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE1 Institutional Fact aaao:ZP114 has geographic scope (is geographic scope of) E53 Place Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE1 Institutional Fact aaao:ZP115 holds over (is held over by) ZE37 Population Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE1 Institutional Fact aaao:ZP2 ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) E1 CRM Entity Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE1 Institutional Fact aaao:ZP3 ascribes intentional relation (is intentional relation ascribed by) E55 Type Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE1 Institutional Fact aaao:ZP4 holds for (holds) E74 Group Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE1 Institutional Fact aaao:ZP75 applies for context (is context for) E5 Event Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE1 Institutional Fact aaao:ZP76 applies for context type (is context type for) E55 Type Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing

Outgoing properties (inherited from ancestors)

Domain Property identifier Range Namespace
ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1 CRM Entity ) crm:P1 is identified by (identifies) E41 Appellation CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1 CRM Entity ) crm:P2 has type (is type of) E55 Type CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1 CRM Entity ) crm:P3 has note E62 String CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1 CRM Entity ) crm:P48 has preferred identifier (is preferred identifier of) E42 Identifier CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1 CRM Entity ) crm:P137 exemplifies (is exemplified by) E55 Type CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1 CRM Entity ) crmdig:L54 is same-as (is same-as) E1 CRM Entity CRMdig version 4.0
ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2 Temporal Entity ) crm:P4 has time-span (is time-span of) E52 Time-Span CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2 Temporal Entity ) crm:P173 starts before or with the end of (ends after or with the start of) E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2 Temporal Entity ) crm:P174 starts before the end of (ends after the start of) E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2 Temporal Entity ) crm:P175 starts before or with the start of (starts after or with the start of) E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2 Temporal Entity ) crm:P176 starts before the start of (starts after the start of) E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2 Temporal Entity ) crm:P182 ends before or with the start of (starts after or with the end of) E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2 Temporal Entity ) crm:P183 ends before the start of (starts after the end of) E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2 Temporal Entity ) crm:P184 ends before or with the end of (ends with or after the end of) E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2 Temporal Entity ) crm:P185 ends before the end of (ends after the end of) E2 Temporal Entity CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3

Incoming properties (this class is range)

Domain Property identifier Range Namespace
E5 Event aaao:ZP111 initiated (was initiated by) ZE1 Institutional Fact Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
E5 Event aaao:ZP112 terminated (was terminated by) ZE1 Institutional Fact Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE1 Institutional Fact aaao:ZP113 has successor status (is successor status of) ZE1 Institutional Fact Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE52 Transformative Symbolic Act aaao:ZP42 intentionally initiated (was intentionally initiated by) ZE1 Institutional Fact Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE52 Transformative Symbolic Act aaao:ZP52 intentionally terminated (was intentionally terminated by) ZE1 Institutional Fact Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE53 Symbolic Act aaao:ZP100 challenged (was challenged by) ZE1 Institutional Fact Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE53 Symbolic Act aaao:ZP101 affirmed (was affirmed by) ZE1 Institutional Fact Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing

Incoming properties (inherited from ancestors)

Domain Property identifier Range Namespace
E1 CRM Entity crmdig:L54 is same-as (is same-as) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CRMdig version 4.0
E2 Temporal Entity crm:P173 starts before or with the end of (ends after or with the start of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E2 Temporal Entity crm:P174 starts before the end of (ends after the start of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E2 Temporal Entity crm:P175 starts before or with the start of (starts after or with the start of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E2 Temporal Entity crm:P176 starts before the start of (starts after the start of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E2 Temporal Entity crm:P182 ends before or with the start of (starts after or with the end of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E2 Temporal Entity crm:P183 ends before the start of (starts after the end of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E2 Temporal Entity crm:P184 ends before or with the end of (ends with or after the end of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E2 Temporal Entity crm:P185 ends before the end of (ends after the end of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E2) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E7 Activity crm:P15 was influenced by (influenced) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E7 Activity crm:P17 was motivated by (motivated) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E13 Attribute Assignment crm:P140 assigned attribute to (was attributed by) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E13 Attribute Assignment crm:P141 assigned (was assigned by) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E17 Type Assignment crm:P41 classified (was classified by) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E24 Physical Human-Made Thing crm:P62 depicts (is depicted by) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E31 Document crm:P70 documents (is documented in) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E32 Authority Document crm:P71 lists (is listed in) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E36 Visual Item crm:P138 represents (has representation) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E83 Type Creation crm:P136 was based on (supported type creation) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E89 Propositional Object crm:P129 is about (is subject of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
E89 Propositional Object crm:P67 refers to (is referred to by) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CIDOC CRM version 7.1.3
S4 Observation crmsci:O16 observed value (value was observed by) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CRMsci version 2.0
D2 Digitization Process crmdig:L60 documents ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CRMdig version 4.0
D29 Annotation Object crmdig:L43 annotates (is annotated by) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) CRMdig version 4.0
ZE1 Institutional Fact aaao:ZP1 has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE1 Institutional Fact aaao:ZP2 ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE2 Appellative Status aaao:ZP5 has appellative subject (is appellative subject of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE4 Classificatory Status aaao:ZP11 has classificatory subject (is classificatory subject of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE5 Function Status aaao:ZP14 has functional subject (is functional subject of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE12 Referential Status aaao:ZP36 ascribes referent (is referent ascribed by) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE14 Similarity Status aaao:ZP43 has similarity subject (is similarity subject of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE14 Similarity Status aaao:ZP44 ascribes similarity target (is similarity target ascribed by) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE15 Set Status aaao:ZP47 has set belonging subject (is set belonging subject of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing
ZE24 Notional Set aaao:ZP51 has former or current set member (is current or former set member of) ZE1 Institutional Fact (is a E1) Art and Architectural Argumentation Ontology Version 1.6 ongoing

Profiles using this class

Label Version Status Last updated

Linked classes graph

Use mouse wheel to zoom in/out.

Comments