Argumentation – I1
I1 Argumentation
Subclass of:
Superclass of:
Scope note:
This class comprises the activity of making honest inferences or observations. An honest inference or observation is one in which the E39 Actor carrying out the I1 Argumentation justifies and believes that the I6 Belief Value associated with resulting I2 Belief about the I4 Proposition Set is the correct value at the time that the activity was undertaken and that any I3 Inference Logic or methodology was correctly applied.
Only one instance of E39 Actor may carry out an instance of I1 Argumentation, though the E39 Actor may, of course, be an instance of E74 Group.
Examples:
My adoption of the belief that Dragendorff type 29 bowls are from the 1st Century AD (I7)
My classification and dating of this bowl (I5)
In First Order Logic:
- I1(x) ⇒ E13(x)
Outgoing properties:
Scope notes
| Show | Scope note | Language | Namespace | View details | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| This class comprises the activity of making honest inferences or observations. An honest inference or observation is one in which the E39 Actor carrying out the I1 Argumentation justifies and believes that the I6 Belief Value associated with resulting I2 Belief about the I4 Proposition Set is the correct value at the time that the activity was undertaken and that any I3 Inference Logic or methodology was correctly applied. Only one instance of E39 Actor may carry out an instance of I1 Argumentation, though the E39 Actor may, of course, be an instance of E74 Group. | en | CRMinf version 0.7 | 0 |
Examples
| Show | Example | Language | Namespace | View details | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| My adoption of the belief that Dragendorff type 29 bowls are from the 1st Century AD (I7) | en | CRMinf version 0.7 | 0 | ||
| My classification and dating of this bowl (I5) | en | CRMinf version 0.7 | 0 |
Additional notes
| Show | Notes | Type | Language | Namespace | View details | Comments |
|---|
Identifier: I1
Official URI: http://www.cidoc-crm.org/extensions/crminf/I1_Argumentation
OntoME URI: https://ontome.net/ontology/c470
Labels
| Label | Language | Last updated | View details | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Argumentation * | en | 2021-06-10 | 0 |
* : Standard label for this language
Namespace
| Namespace | Last updated |
|---|---|
| CRMinf version 1.0 | 2024-09-16 |
| CRMinf version 0.7 | 2021-05-07 |
Parent classes
| Class | Class namespace | Relation defined in | Justification | View details | Edit | Delete | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E13 Attribute Assignment | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | CRMinf version 0.7 |
|
0 |
Ancestor classes
| Class | Depth | Class namespace | Via |
|---|---|---|---|
| E1 CRM Entity | 6 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E2 |
| E1 CRM Entity | 6 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E92 |
| E1 CRM Entity | 7 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - C46 - C10 - C4 - C1 - E2 |
| E1 CRM Entity | 7 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - C46 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E2 |
| E1 CRM Entity | 7 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - C46 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E92 |
| E1 CRM Entity | 7 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E2 - S15 |
| E1 CRM Entity | 7 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E92 - C5 |
| E1 CRM Entity | 8 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - C46 - C10 - C4 - C1 - E2 - S15 |
| E1 CRM Entity | 8 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - C46 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E2 - S15 |
| E1 CRM Entity | 8 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - C46 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E92 - C5 |
| E2 Temporal Entity | 5 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - E7 - E5 - E4 |
| E2 Temporal Entity | 6 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - C46 - C10 - C4 - C1 |
| E2 Temporal Entity | 6 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - C46 - E7 - E5 - E4 |
| E4 Period | 4 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - E7 - E5 |
| E4 Period | 5 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - C46 - E7 - E5 |
| E5 Event | 3 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - E7 |
| E5 Event | 4 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - C46 - E7 |
| E7 Activity | 2 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 |
| E7 Activity | 3 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - C46 |
| E92 Spacetime Volume | 5 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - E7 - E5 - E4 |
| E92 Spacetime Volume | 6 | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 | E13 - C46 - E7 - E5 - E4 |
| C1 Entity Quality | 5 | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing | E13 - C46 - C10 - C4 |
| Thing | 7 | OntoME internal model - active version | E13 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E2 - E1 |
| Thing | 7 | OntoME internal model - active version | E13 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E92 - E1 |
| Thing | 8 | OntoME internal model - active version | E13 - C46 - C10 - C4 - C1 - E2 - E1 |
| Thing | 8 | OntoME internal model - active version | E13 - C46 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E2 - E1 |
| Thing | 8 | OntoME internal model - active version | E13 - C46 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E92 - E1 |
| Thing | 8 | OntoME internal model - active version | E13 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E2 - S15 - E1 |
| Thing | 8 | OntoME internal model - active version | E13 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E92 - C5 - E1 |
| Thing | 9 | OntoME internal model - active version | E13 - C46 - C10 - C4 - C1 - E2 - S15 - E1 |
| Thing | 9 | OntoME internal model - active version | E13 - C46 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E2 - S15 - E1 |
| Thing | 9 | OntoME internal model - active version | E13 - C46 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E92 - C5 - E1 |
| S15 Observable Entity | 6 | CRMsci version 1.2.3 | E13 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E2 |
| S15 Observable Entity | 7 | CRMsci version 1.2.3 | E13 - C46 - C10 - C4 - C1 - E2 |
| S15 Observable Entity | 7 | CRMsci version 1.2.3 | E13 - C46 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E2 |
| C5 Abstract Region | 6 | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing | E13 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E92 |
| C5 Abstract Region | 7 | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing | E13 - C46 - E7 - E5 - E4 - E92 |
| C4 Intention | 4 | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing | E13 - C46 - C10 |
| C10 Intentional Event | 3 | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing | E13 - C46 |
| C46 Intentional Expression | 2 | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing | E13 |
Child and descendant classes
| Class | Depth | Class namespace | Via |
|---|---|---|---|
| S3 Measurement by Sampling | 3 | CRMsci version 1.2.3 | S4 - S21 |
| S4 Observation | 1 | CRMsci version 1.2.3 | |
| S5 Inference Making | 1 | CRMsci version 1.2.3 | |
| S6 Data Evaluation | 2 | CRMsci version 1.2.3 | S5 |
| S7 Simulation or Prediction | 2 | CRMsci version 1.2.3 | S5 |
| S8 Categorical Hypothesis Building | 2 | CRMsci version 1.2.3 | S5 |
| S19 Encounter Event | 2 | CRMsci version 1.2.3 | S4 |
| S21 Measurement | 2 | CRMsci version 1.2.3 | S4 |
| I5 Inference Making | 1 | CRMinf version 0.7 | |
| I7 Belief Adoption | 1 | CRMinf version 0.7 |
Related classes
| Relation | Class | Class namespace | Justification | Relation defined in | View details | Edit | Delete | Comments |
|---|
Outgoing properties (this class is domain)
| Domain | Property identifier | Range | Namespace |
|---|---|---|---|
| I1 Argumentation | crminf:J2 concluded that (was concluded by) | I2 Belief | CRMinf version 0.7 |
Outgoing properties (inherited from ancestors)
Incoming properties (this class is range)
| Domain | Property identifier | Range | Namespace |
|---|
Incoming properties (inherited from ancestors)
| Domain | Property identifier | Range | Namespace |
|---|---|---|---|
| E1 CRM Entity | crmdig:L54 is same-as (is same-as) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CRMdig version 3.2.1 |
| E1 CRM Entity | sdh:P10 time-independent entity association | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| E1 CRM Entity | sdh:P18 is identifying component of range class (range class has identity defining component) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| E1 CRM Entity | sdh:P2 domain class has identity defining component (is identity defining component of domain class) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| E1 CRM Entity | sdh:P70 same resource in the world as (same as) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| E1 CRM Entity | sdh:P71 could be the same entity as (inverse of could be the same entity as) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| E2 Temporal Entity | sdh:P1 involves (is involved in) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| E2 Temporal Entity | crm:P114 is equal in time to | I1 Argumentation (is a E2) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E2 Temporal Entity | crm:P115 finishes (is finished by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E2) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E2 Temporal Entity | crm:P116 starts (is started by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E2) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E2 Temporal Entity | crm:P117 occurs during (includes) | I1 Argumentation (is a E2) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E2 Temporal Entity | crm:P118 overlaps in time with (is overlapped in time by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E2) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E2 Temporal Entity | crm:P119 meets in time with (is met in time by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E2) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E2 Temporal Entity | crm:P120 occurs before (occurs after) | I1 Argumentation (is a E2) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E2 Temporal Entity | sdh:P5 is part of (has part) | I1 Argumentation (is a E2) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| E4 Period | crm:P9 consists of (forms part of) | I1 Argumentation (is a E4) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E5 Event | crmsci:O13 triggers (is triggered by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E5) | CRMsci version 1.2.3 |
| E5 Event | sdh:P8 effects (result from) | I1 Argumentation (is a C1) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| E5 Event | sdh:P9 ends (is ended by) | I1 Argumentation (is a C1) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| E7 Activity | crm:P134 continued (was continued by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E7) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E7 Activity | crm:P15 was influenced by (influenced) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E7 Activity | crm:P17 was motivated by (motivated) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E7 Activity | crm:P20 had specific purpose (was purpose of) | I1 Argumentation (is a E5) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E13 Attribute Assignment | crm:P140 assigned attribute to (was attributed by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E13 Attribute Assignment | crm:P141 assigned (was assigned by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E16 Measurement | crm:P39 measured (was measured by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E17 Type Assignment | crm:P41 classified (was classified by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E24 Physical Man-Made Thing | crm:P62 depicts (is depicted by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E31 Document | crm:P70 documents (is documented in) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E32 Authority Document | crm:P71 lists (is listed in) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E36 Visual Item | crm:P138 represents (has representation) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E83 Type Creation | crm:P136 was based on (supported type creation) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E89 Propositional Object | crm:P129 is about (is subject of) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E89 Propositional Object | crm:P67 refers to (is referred to by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E92 Spacetime Volume | crm:P10 falls within (contains) | I1 Argumentation (is a E92) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E92 Spacetime Volume | crm:P132 overlaps with | I1 Argumentation (is a E92) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E92 Spacetime Volume | crm:P133 is separated from | I1 Argumentation (is a E92) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| E93 Presence | crm:P166 was a presence of (had presence) | I1 Argumentation (is a E92) | CIDOC CRM version 6.2 |
| F29 Recording Event | frbroo:R20 recorded (was recorded through) | I1 Argumentation (is a E2) | FRBRoo version 2.4 |
| F35 Nomen Use Statement | frbroo:R38 refers to thema (is thema of) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | FRBRoo version 2.4 |
| F40 Identifier Assignment | frbroo:R45 assigned to (was assigned by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | FRBRoo version 2.4 |
| F51 Pursuit | frbroo:R59 had typical subject (was typical subject of) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | FRBRoo version 2.4 |
| F52 Name Use Activity | frbroo:R63 named (was named by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | FRBRoo version 2.4 |
| C11 Appellation in a Language | sdh:P11 is appellation for language of (has appellation for language) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| S4 Observation | crmsci:O16 observed value (value was observed by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CRMsci version 1.2.3 |
| S4 Observation | crmsci:O8 observed (was observed by) | I1 Argumentation (is a S15) | CRMsci version 1.2.3 |
| S6 Data Evaluation | crmsci:O11 described (was described by) | I1 Argumentation (is a S15) | CRMsci version 1.2.3 |
| S21 Measurement | crmsci:O24 measured (was measured by) | I1 Argumentation (is a S15) | CRMsci version 1.2.3 |
| S22 Segment of Matter | crmsci:O23 is defined by (defines) | I1 Argumentation (is a E92) | CRMsci version 1.2.3 |
| D2 Digitization Process | crmdig:L60 documents | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CRMdig version 3.2.1 |
| D29 Annotation Object | crmdig:L43 annotates (is annotated by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | CRMdig version 3.2.1 |
| C15 Participation | sdh-so:P11 is participation in (has participation) | I1 Argumentation (is a E5) | SDHSS Social, legal and economic life ongoing |
| C2 Propositional Situation | sdh:P33 interprets (is interpreted by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E5) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| C2 Propositional Situation | sdh:P51 is interpretation of (is interpreted by) | I1 Argumentation (is a C10) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| C16 Participant Description | sdh-so:P25 is participant in (has participant) | I1 Argumentation (is a E5) | SDHSS Social, legal and economic life ongoing |
| C19 Legal Integration | sdh-so:P27 is integration of (is integrated by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | SDHSS Social, legal and economic life ongoing |
| C25 Intentional Collective | sdh:P36 has manifestation in (is manifestation of) | I1 Argumentation (is a E4) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| C30 Connotation | sdh:P39 is connotation of (has connotation) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| C23 Identification | crm-sup:P18 is identification of (has identification) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | SDHSS CIDOC CRM supplement – ongoing |
| C8 Intentional Composition | sdh:P53 has intentional component (is component of) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| C8 Intentional Composition | sdh:P54 is intentional component of (has intentional component) | I1 Argumentation (is a E1) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| C10 Intentional Event | sdh:P3 effects (is the result of) | I1 Argumentation (is a C4) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| C10 Intentional Event | sdh:P4 ends (is ended by) | I1 Argumentation (is a C4) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| C10 Intentional Event | sdh:P43 has setting (is setting for) | I1 Argumentation (is a E5) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| C35 Actor's Quality in Relation to an Event | sdh-so:P57 is quality in relation to (has related actor's quality) | I1 Argumentation (is a E5) | SDHSS Social, legal and economic life ongoing |
| C35 Actor's Quality in Relation to an Event | sdh-so:P60 is quality in relation to intentional event (has related actor's quality) | I1 Argumentation (is a C10) | SDHSS Social, legal and economic life ongoing |
| C38 Presence of a Thing | sdh-so:P76 is presence in (has presence) | I1 Argumentation (is a E5) | SDHSS Social, legal and economic life ongoing |
| C57 Quantifiable Quality of a Spatio-Temporal Phenomenon | sdh:P75 is quantifiable quality of (has quantifiable quality) | I1 Argumentation (is a E4) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| C64 Event Classification | sdh:P82 classifies (is classified by) | I1 Argumentation (is a E5) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| C66 Involvement of a Thing | sdh:P84 involved in (has involved object) | I1 Argumentation (is a E7) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
| C71 Quantifiable Quality of an Intentional Event | sdh:P89 is quantifiable quality of (has quantifiable quality) | I1 Argumentation (is a C10) | SDHSS Semantic Data for Humanities and Social Sciences CIDOC CRM Extension ongoing |
Profiles using this class
| Label | Version | Status | Last updated |
|---|
Linked classes graph
Use mouse wheel to zoom in/out.
Comments
No comment found.